Whole Wheat Sourdough/Natural Yeast Breadmachine Bread


This recipe is for whole wheat sourdough bread done in the breadmachine. I make it almost every day. Last week I went on an 8 hour road trip. I took my sourdough bread with me, presliced. In my pre-Nourishing Traditions days I used to take bagels for us to munch on for road trips. I finally decided that the store-bought bagels tasted like play-doh. (OK, true confessions, yes I tasted play-doh as a child.) This sourdough bread tasted so much better and it’s much more nutritious for us than grocery store bagels! I don’t get the carby-overload feeling when I eat it. When I am home, frequently for lunch, I will toast this bread, slather the butter on, and then melt some cheese on it for a nutrient-dense grilled cheese sandwich. Doesn’t it look nummy? And the smell is so heavenly!!!!!

Over a month ago, I got to attend a class given by Melissa Richardson, coauthor of the following book:


I don’t have time to give a recap of the whole class here, but let’s just say that Melissa gave the best explanation of why whole grains should be soured, soaked, or sprouted before being eaten. It all has to do with phytic acid. She used a great, funny metaphor to explain it. That’s what you get when you have a writer who also is a baker. Melissa said she took a writing class from her coauthor, Caleb Warnock, and she paid him in bread when he started noticing that the treats of baked goods she brought to class were delicious and nutritious! Her bread made with natural yeast was so good for him that he was able to get off his medication for acid reflux that he had been using for over ten years! Amazingly enough, the lady who hosted the class said that her husband, who has been diagnosed with celiac disease by his doctor, can eat the bread that she makes using Melissa’s recipes.



Whole grains can be good for you if you prepare them the right way! If you don’t, then you are asking for digestive and other troubles, like tooth decay. All this talk about gluten intolerance and allergies could largely evaporate if we learned how to prepare our grains with fermenting (sourdough, aka natural yeast), soaking, or sprouting.

See how light and fluffy this bread looks? Yes, it’s whole wheat sourdough bread! This is just what Melissa’s samples looked like in the class. It was so great to see, or have a vision, of what sourdough bread can look like. It doesn’t have to be dense, solid slabs that could be used as bricks or paperweights! I came home and replicated her bread in the picture above. Her bread really did look just like this.

I already had her book but it was worth it go to her class to hear her explanation, which as far as I can tell, is not in the book, and to get a sourdough starter from her! She also had some more info not in her book but on the handout, so I am really glad I listened to the Spirit telling me to go to the class, even though my pride/or I guess it was the Enemy telling me, “You don’t need to go, you already have the book.”



I had been using a starter since last October but I learned a few things from going to Melissa’s class. Namely, that your starter should show bubbles that you can see in the dough. If your starter is not bubbly, you need to reduce the amount, not use the starter yet, and start over by feeding it again, as she says in her book. You can go to her Facebook page here and watch her videos.  Seeing bubbles is a key! That is why it’s best to use a glass jar. Here is my starter nice and bubbly:


So I went home and fed my starter using her handout as an instruction. I am so happy to say that I kept the starter alive, or did not kill it, and here it is above, having survived several weeks. I went to her book and used the recipe for bread machine bread. It overflowed way too much! I had to spend some time scraping baked bread on the inside of the machine. I studied her recipe in the book and then I noticed it said “Makes two loaves.” Ahhh, no wonder I had Mt. Vesuvius action going on! But there was no other instruction in the recipe, like “Divide the dough in half.”

So I experimented with the recipe and found that if I cut down the amount of natural yeast (aka sourdough start), and kept all the remaining ingredients the same, the recipe worked perfectly.

So here is my modified recipe that works just right in my machine. Hopefully it will work in yours. Hint: if you don’t have a breadmachine, check your local thrift store. That’s where I got mine, really cheap, only $5! ebay might work too.

Whole Wheat Sourdough Bread from Breadmachine

Put the following wet ingredients in your breadmachine loaf pan:

2 T softened or melted butter

1 3/4 c water

2 T honey

1 c sourdough, aka natural yeast start

Then add the dry ingredients:

4 1/2 c whole wheat flour, I use white winter wheat

1 1/4 tsp salt

Install the pan properly so it is “seated”  in your breadmachine.

Choose the longest setting for whole wheat bread. On my machine this is setting #2, which takes 4 hours and 10 minutes. When you hear the machine start mixing, which for my machine is 30 minutes into the cycle, take a rubber scraper and help the machine out by bringing up the sides of the dough mixtures. Watch the mixture form into a nice, smooth, clean ball. If it doesn’t form into a ball, add more flour until it does. If there’s too much flour add a little water.

Hint: If I don’t have time to wait for the 30 minutes into the cycle, I will choose the “Dough” setting on my machine. That allows the machine to start kneading the mixture right away. I will watch and make sure a ball forms. Then I will cancel the dough cycle and choose the “whole wheat bread” cycle and start it over. Ever since I have followed what I just wrote in these last two paragraphs I have had perfect bread every time!

When it’s done, smother with lots of butter and honey while it’s hot and enjoy!

Here is one video by Melissa about how to do sourdough:


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Whole Wheat Sourdough/Natural Yeast Breadmachine Bread

  1. kermofutah says:

    I’ve been looking for some sort of recipe for a fluffy sourdough bread! I’d like to start making my bread again, but having switched from white to wheat flour, I haven’t been able to get it right for sandwiches. Thank you! Is the taste super sour or more mild?


    • treeoflifemama says:

      It is super sour depending on how long you let the starter ferment. If you just let it ferment for a day it’s not super sour, just a bit sour. But if you and your kids are used to store bought white bread you will think it’s super sour.


  2. Pingback: The Bread Geek Speaks! | Tree of Life Mothering

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s